Night Guards

Custom Night Guard vs Over The Counter Reddit Discussion

custom night guard or store bought reddit

Night guards play a vital role in safeguarding our dental health, especially for those grappling with issues like teeth grinding and jaw clenching. Amidst the vast expanse of the internet, discussions on platforms like Reddit often serve as a sounding board for individuals seeking advice on dental care. One recurring debate that catches the eye is the choice between custom-made night guards and their over-the-counter counterparts.

In this article, we’ll delve into the intricacies of this discussion, exploring the pros and cons of both options to help you make an informed decision about the best teeth protection for you.

Understanding Night Guards

Night guards are dental appliances designed to protect teeth and alleviate discomfort caused by nighttime habits like teeth grinding (bruxism) or temporomandibular joint disorder (TMJ). These conditions, if left untreated, can lead to tooth damage, jaw pain, and other oral health issues. Night guards work by creating a protective barrier between the upper and lower teeth, absorbing the force of grinding or clenching and preventing wear and tear on the enamel. By wearing a night guard while sleeping, individuals can significantly reduce the risk of dental complications and wake up feeling more refreshed.

Custom Night Guards

Custom night guards are meticulously crafted to fit the unique contours of an individual’s teeth and jaw. This personalized approach begins with either a visit to the dentist, where precise impressions of the teeth are taken or by purchasing online and taking your own dental impressions.

These impressions serve as the basis for creating a custom-fitted night guard that offers optimal comfort and effectiveness. Custom night guards are known for their superior fit, durability, and ability to address specific dental issues with precision. While they may involve a higher upfront cost, the benefits of a custom-fit night guard often outweigh the initial investment, providing long-term protection and comfort for the wearer.

Over-The-Counter Night Guards

Over-the-counter (OTC) night guards offer a convenient and accessible alternative to custom-made options. Available in drugstores or online, these pre-made night guards come in standard sizes and designs, making them easy to purchase without the need for dental appointments or impressions. While OTC night guards are generally more affordable than custom ones, they may not provide the same level of comfort or effectiveness.

One of the primary drawbacks of OTC night guards is their one-size-fits-all approach, which can result in a poor fit and discomfort for some users. Additionally, they may not address individual dental needs as effectively as custom night guards, potentially leading to less satisfactory outcomes for those with specific oral health concerns.

store bought night guard vs custom made night guard

Reddit Discussions

Reddit serves as a vibrant hub for discussions on a wide range of topics, including dental care and night guards. Within the Reddit community, users often share their experiences, ask for advice, and engage in debates about the merits of custom versus over-the-counter night guards.

Common themes in these discussions include the importance of comfort, effectiveness, and cost-effectiveness. Some users advocate for custom night guards, praising their tailored fit and superior performance, while others opt for the convenience and affordability of over-the-counter options despite potential drawbacks. Anecdotes and testimonials shared on Reddit provide valuable insights into real-world experiences, helping individuals navigate the decision-making process when choosing a night guard that best suits their needs.

Custom Night Guards:

  1. Comfort and Fit: Many users praise the comfort and snug fit of custom night guards, highlighting how they feel like a natural extension of their teeth. Some users report that custom guards are so comfortable that they forget they’re wearing them.
  2. Effectiveness: Users often mention how custom night guards effectively alleviate their teeth grinding or jaw clenching symptoms. They appreciate the personalized design that targets their specific dental issues, leading to improved sleep quality and reduced morning jaw pain.
  3. Durability: Custom night guards are frequently lauded for their durability and longevity. Users note that despite the initial investment, custom guards tend to last longer and maintain their shape better than over-the-counter options, ultimately providing better value over time.

Over-The-Counter Night Guards:

  1. Convenience: Many users appreciate the convenience of purchasing over-the-counter night guards from local drugstores or online retailers without the need for dental appointments or impressions. They value the accessibility and immediate availability of these options.
  2. Affordability: Cost-conscious users often opt for over-the-counter night guards due to their lower price point compared to custom-made alternatives. They find these options more budget-friendly, especially for those who may not have dental insurance coverage.
  3. Mixed Reviews on Fit and Comfort: While some users find over-the-counter night guards adequate in terms of fit and comfort, others report issues with poor fit, discomfort, or difficulty adjusting to the generic design. There’s often a consensus that the fit can vary greatly depending on the individual’s mouth shape and size.
  4. Effectiveness: Opinions on the effectiveness of over-the-counter night guards vary. While some users find relief from teeth grinding and jaw clenching, others express dissatisfaction with the level of protection and symptom relief compared to custom-made guards.

Common questions Reddit users ask about custom night guards vs. over the counter options:

Is a custom night guard really worth the extra cost compared to an over-the-counter one?

Yes, a custom night guard is worth the extra cost compared to an over-the-counter one. Custom guards offer superior fit, comfort, and durability due to their personalized design and higher-quality materials.

Are there any specific dental conditions or concerns that make a custom night guard more necessary than an over-the-counter one?

Yes, conditions like severe bruxism, TMJ disorder, or misaligned teeth often require a custom night guard for optimal fit, comfort, and effectiveness.

Are there any risks associated with using over-the-counter night guards instead of getting a custom one from a dentist?

Yes, risks associated with using over-the-counter night guards include poor fit, discomfort, and potentially exacerbating dental issues due to inadequate protection.

Do custom night guards require regular maintenance or adjustments, and how does that compare to over-the-counter options?

Yes, custom night guards may require occasional adjustments or maintenance to ensure proper fit and effectiveness, typically done by a dentist. This compares to over-the-counter options, which generally do not offer customization or adjustments and may need replacement if they become worn or uncomfortable.

Can over-the-counter night guards provide the same level of protection as custom ones for severe cases of teeth grinding or jaw clenching?

Over-the-counter night guards may not provide the same level of protection as custom ones for severe cases of teeth grinding or jaw clenching. Custom guards offer a precise fit tailored to individual dental needs, providing superior comfort and effectiveness compared to generic OTC options.

How often do custom night guards need to be replaced compared to over-the-counter ones?

Custom night guards typically last longer than over-the-counter ones due to their higher quality materials and precise fit. While over-the-counter guards may need replacement more frequently due to wear and tear, custom guards can often endure for several years with proper care and maintenance.

Expert Insights

Dental professionals consistently advocate for the benefits of custom night guards over their over-the-counter counterparts. Dentists emphasize the importance of a precise fit in maximizing comfort and effectiveness while minimizing potential discomfort or oral health risks. Custom night guards, crafted under the supervision of trained professionals, are tailored to address individual dental needs and provide optimal protection against teeth grinding and jaw clenching.

Additionally, dentists stress the significance of regular dental check-ups to monitor the condition of the night guard and make any necessary adjustments to ensure continued efficacy. While over-the-counter options offer convenience and affordability, they may fall short in delivering the personalized care and long-term benefits that custom night guards provide.


In conclusion, the debate between custom night guards and over-the-counter options is multifaceted, with considerations ranging from comfort and effectiveness to cost and convenience. While both types of night guards have their merits, it’s evident that custom-made guards offer a superior level of personalized care and protection for individuals dealing with teeth grinding and jaw clenching. However, the decision ultimately depends on individual preferences, budget constraints, and dental health needs.

Whether opting for the precision fit of a custom night guard or the affordability of an over-the-counter solution, prioritizing dental health is paramount. Consultation with a dentist can provide valuable guidance in selecting the night guard option that best suits one’s needs and ensures long-term oral health and comfort.

Want to learn more? Visit our help center today!


sentinel mouthguards author
Ashely Notarmaso

Ashely Notarmaso is the author behind the Sentinel Mouth Guard Blog. She is the CEO and founder of Sentinel Mouth Guards (Founded in 2012) Her long-time work in the dental mouth guard arena and her excellent ability to listen to customer concerns in this often contradictory field has laid the groundwork to explore night guard/mouth guard fabrication in-depth and address real concerns. With the help of her team, she has created a unique fabrication method that promises a great fitting custom oral appliance every time. Amazon’s choice for #1 mouth guard! Visit the online store

Verified By